TY - JOUR
T1 - Sensitivity analysis for unmeasured confounding in the estimation of marginal causal effects
AU - Ciocanea-Teodorescu, Iuliana
AU - Gabriel, E. E.
AU - Sjolander, A.
PY - 2022
Y1 - 2022
N2 - One of the main threats to the validity of causal effect estimates from observational data is the existence of unmeasured confounders. A plethora of methods has been proposed to quantify deviation from conditional exchangeability, which arises when confounding is not properly accounted for, with each method having its own set of limitations and underlying assumptions. Few methods both scale well with the increasing complexity of potential measured confounders and avoid making strong simplifying assumptions about the effect of the unmeasured confounder within strata of the measured confounders. For binary outcomes, we propose a quantification of the deviation from conditional exchangeability, based on standardization within levels of the exposure, which can accommodate any type of measured and unmeasured confounders or desired estimand. In the case of binary exposure, this amounts to varying two parameters across a grid of values, no matter how complex the measured confounding. We propose three methods of estimation for the causal estimand of interest under our proposed sensitivity analysis. This allows for an easily applied, easily interpreted sensitivity analysis that makes minimal assumptions about the type of unmeasured confounding and places no limits on the complexity of the potential measured confounders.
AB - One of the main threats to the validity of causal effect estimates from observational data is the existence of unmeasured confounders. A plethora of methods has been proposed to quantify deviation from conditional exchangeability, which arises when confounding is not properly accounted for, with each method having its own set of limitations and underlying assumptions. Few methods both scale well with the increasing complexity of potential measured confounders and avoid making strong simplifying assumptions about the effect of the unmeasured confounder within strata of the measured confounders. For binary outcomes, we propose a quantification of the deviation from conditional exchangeability, based on standardization within levels of the exposure, which can accommodate any type of measured and unmeasured confounders or desired estimand. In the case of binary exposure, this amounts to varying two parameters across a grid of values, no matter how complex the measured confounding. We propose three methods of estimation for the causal estimand of interest under our proposed sensitivity analysis. This allows for an easily applied, easily interpreted sensitivity analysis that makes minimal assumptions about the type of unmeasured confounding and places no limits on the complexity of the potential measured confounders.
KW - Conditional exchangeability
KW - Sensitivity analysis
KW - Unmeasured confounding
KW - INFERENCE
U2 - 10.1093/biomet/asac018
DO - 10.1093/biomet/asac018
M3 - Journal article
SN - 0006-3444
VL - 109
SP - 1101
EP - 1116
JO - Biometrika
JF - Biometrika
IS - 4
ER -