Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Encounters with medicines among ethnic minorities with chronic conditions: Perspectives from policy, professionals and patients

  • Anna Mygind

    Research output: Ph.D Thesis › Ph.D. Thesis

    Abstract

    Background: The Danish healthcare sector, including community pharmacies, faces a modern challenge: a new and growing population group consisting of ethnic minorities with chronic conditions, associated with the prevalence of multiple conditions, poly-pharmacy and adherence issues.
    Aim: The aim of the study was to explore the challenges of encounters with medicines among ethnic minorities with chronic conditions in Denmark, exemplified by policy, professional and patient perspectives. Implications for community pharmacies was a particular focus.
    Methods: The study drew on different methods, types of data, definitions of ethnicity, and people studied. Sub-study I exemplified the policy perspective by analysing how ethnic minorities at risk of vitamin D deficiency were constructed in current Danish policy documents regarding vitamin D supplements. The documents were analysed with inspiration from social constructivism with focus on definitions and explanations of ethnic minorities at risk of vitamin D deficiency. The professional perspective was exemplified through sub-study II, a questionnaire survey of pharmacists and pharmacy assistants working at the 55 Danish community pharmacies in the five local councils with the highest number of immigrant inhabitants. This sub-study explored the challenges that Danish community pharmacy staff encounter when serving non-Western immigrant customers. The patient perspective was exemplified by sub-studies III and IV. Sub-study III was based on a hermeneutic analysis of interviews with people with Pakistani background, type 2 diabetes and at least one other chronic condition, focusing on lived experiences with medicine use during Ramadan, reasons for fasting, and experiences with counselling on medicines. Sub-study IV encompassed an analysis of interviews with poly-pharmacy patients with non-Western immigrant background focusing on perceptions of disease aetiology and the effect of own behaviour on health.
    Results: Eight different constructions of ethnic minorities at risk of vitamin D deficiency were found in the ten policy documents identified in sub-study I. Most documents agreed that skin colour and skin covering were part of the definition of ethnic minorities at risk. Major discrepancies were found regarding the importance attributed to the Islamic religion, other traditions, immigration, gender and age, and an evolutionary explanation for increased risk. Some documents included several unclear definitions of ethnic minorities at risk. The response rate in sub-study II was 76% (84/110). Most respondents found that the needs of immigrant customers were not sufficiently assessed at the pharmacy counter (n=55, 65%), and that their latest encounter with an immigrant customer was less satisfactory than a similar encounter with an ethnic Danish customer (n=48, 57%) (significantly more pharmacists than assistants (OR=3.19 [95% CI: 1.27-8.04])). Forty-two percent (n=35) perceived that immigrant customers put pressure on pharmacy staff resources, while 27% (n=23) found that the immigrant customer group makes work more interesting. More pharmacists than assistants agreed on the latter (OR=3.43 [95% CI: 1.04-11.33]). Within the past 14 days, 86% (n=72) experienced that immigrant customers had not understood their advice and counselling, whereas 49% (n=41) experienced lack of understanding by ethnic Danes; and 30% (n=25) had consciously refrained from counselling an immigrant, whereas 19% (n=16) had held back with an ethnic Dane. Use of underaged children as interpreters during the past month was reported by 79% (n=66) of respondents. Regarding suggestions on how to improve encounters with immigrant customers, most respondents listed interventions aiming at immigrants, general practitioners, and pharmaceutical companies. In sub-study III, all six interviewees pointed out that Islam allows ill people to refrain from fasting during Ramadan. However, all had fasted during Ramadan despite being diagnosed with type 2 diabetes. While fasting, they adapted their use of medicines in different ways, e.g. changing the time of intake or skipping morning medicines. Fasting during Ramadan meant a feeling of improvement in well-being for all interviewees. Reasons for this improvement included physiological, social and religious aspects. Healthcare professionals were rarely included in the decision-making process on whether or not to fast. Instead, friends and relatives, especially those with type 2 diabetes, were considered important to the decision-making process. The majority of the 26 participants in substudy IV perceived stress to be a main cause of their diseases for reasons that included having left their country of origin and family, worry over the political situation in their country of origin, and the problems involved in living as an immigrant in Denmark. Most of the participants perceived their own efforts as having little impact on their own health status, although some considered their efforts as having considerable influence.
    Conclusions: Encounters with medicines among ethnic minorities with chronic conditions were found not optimal as explored from policy, professional and patient perspectives. Ethnicity was differently and unclearly defined in vitamin D policy documents; community pharmacy staff perceived encounters with ethnic minorities to be less optimal than encounters with ethnic Danes in terms of sub-optimal counselling and frequent use of under-aged children as interpreters; and patients were found to rarely talk to healthcare professionals about changing medicine intake during Ramadan, despite its clinical relevance. Potential for improving the encounters includes better access to language assistance and increased focus on cultural sensitivity in the community pharmacy sector and elsewhere in the healthcare sector.
    Original languageEnglish
    Place of PublicationKøbenhavn
    Publisher
    Publication statusPublished - Jan 2013

    Bibliographical note

    PhD thesis

    Cite this