Abstract
Background: vaccines are complex products used in healthy populations. They should be carefully regulated, and benefits should clearly outweigh risks. Objectives: To describe the evidence used to support benefit-risk evaluations of vaccines centrally assessed by the European Medicines Agency (EMA), and to identify if real-world data (RWD) was used throughout the vaccine life cycle. Methods: Cohort study of vaccines approved in the European Union. Inclusion criteria comprised having ATC code J07 and being centrally approved between 2012 and 2022. We collected data from regulatory documents, study protocols, and, when necessary, from scientific publications. Vaccines were followed from initial approval up to March 2023. Results: We included 31 vaccines addressing 17 therapeutic areas. More than 390 studies were used in the process of initial marketing authorisation (MA) and monitoring, and 174 studies were listed in initial risk management plans. We also identified 93 studies in the EU PAS register. At MA, all vaccines had at least one pivotal trial and 27 vaccines had at least one supportive study. Most pivotal trials were randomized, double-blinded and active-controlled, with immunogenicity endpoints as primary outcome. RWD was used for extension of indications and monitoring of at least 4 vaccines, and the undertaking of RWE studies was foreseen in the RMP of at least 17 vaccines. Discussion: Our study revealed an important reliance on randomized controlled trials with individual-level randomization, and a significant focus on immunogenicity endpoints. The use of RWD in vaccine assessments so far has been restricted to COVID-19, and despite its challenges and limitations, we believe that efforts to expand adoption of RWE in continuous benefit-risk assessments should be made. We further highlight the need to enhance data transparency and reporting standards since heterogeneity among regulatory documents made it difficult to identify all the studies considered in vaccine evaluations.
Original language | English |
---|---|
Article number | 126186 |
Journal | Vaccine |
Volume | 42 |
Issue number | 21 |
Number of pages | 12 |
ISSN | 0264-410X |
DOIs | |
Publication status | Published - 2024 |
Bibliographical note
Publisher Copyright:© 2024 The Authors
Keywords
- Assessment
- Benefit-risk
- Marketing authorisation
- Regulatory authority
- Vaccines