Skip to main navigation Skip to search Skip to main content

Truth, Rhetoric and History in Josephus' Against Apion

  • Jonathan James Shaw Davies

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceeding › Book chapter › Research › peer-review

Abstract

While not a work of historiography per se, many of the central concerns of Josephus’ apologetic rhetorical treatise Against Apion are historical or historiographical in nature. This treatise, therefore, could very productively be brought into the conversation about the relationship between rhetoric and historiographical ‘truth’ in antiquity. Josephus asserts strongly the superiority of non-Greek forms of historiography practiced by some of the cultures of the Eastern Mediterranean (Egyptians, Phoenicians, Babylonians and Jews) over the Greek tradition, precisely on the grounds that Greek historiography is excessively rhetorical. In so doing, Josephus deploys rhetorical tropes about the distorting power of rhetoric against rhetorical historiography itself. He proposes one central virtue – symphonia, or consensus – as the hallmark par excellence of a reliable historiographical tradition, enabling him to castigate Greek historiography for its polyphonic nature and traditions of denigration of predecessor. He posits several motivations – desire for novelty, overwhelming concern for eloquence, spite and envy – for historians’ distortions of the ‘truth’, and, in his handling of the works of Manetho, he develops seemingly original insights into the nature of the relationship between the historian and his sources. This chapter will aim to read this tantalizing treatise in the light of current thinking about rhetoric and truth in Greek and Roman historiography, exploring how Josephus’ thought relates to these traditions as well as how his distinctive vision can potentially complicate our broader understanding of this question.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationRoman Historiography: Nature and Methodologies
EditorsMads Lindholmer
PublisherBrill
Publication statusAccepted/In press - 2025

Cite this